AnandTech Year In Review 2019: Flagship Mobileby Andrei Frumusanu on December 26, 2019 8:00 AM EST
2019 is coming to an end, and it’s time again to look back at what the industry has brought us. This year, we saw a lot of hardware improvements from all the various vendors, with a big focus on bringing out new distinctive designs. We’ve seen some exotic devices in the form of foldable phones for the first time ever, and even some more traditional designs dared to implement design cues such as mechanical pop-out cameras. While designs were sometimes the main differentiating factors, most of the time the key selling points of 2019 devices were big upgrades in their camera capabilities. Here we’ve seen huge leaps from almost all the vendors, and the year definitely will be remembered mainly for the innovations in photography.
Triple Cameras Become A Must-Have in 2019
Undoubtedly the biggest trend in 2019 devices, affecting both design as well as features, has been the standardisation of triple-camera setups. A trend started in 2018 by Huawei, it’s essentially become a main-stay of almost every flagship device in 2019, and a must-have for any phone which takes photography seriously. The feature is now so widespread that we’ve even seen it trickle down to the mid-range, and even sometimes lower end devices.
In most cases, the new module being added to the camera array was the ultra-wide-angle unit. The UWA isn’t exactly a new innovation; LG was the first in the industry to employ it several years ago, and Huawei last year perfected it in the Mate 20 and 20 Pro by dramatically raising the bar in terms of picture quality.
The adoption of the UWA by Samsung, Apple, OPPO, OnePlus, Sony, Xiaomi and many others means that the new camera perspective is ubiquitous for almost all 2019 devices, and it’s a fantastic addition to the capture experience not only for still pictures, but also for video recording.
We’ve also seen some innovations on the telephoto modules by some vendors. Huawei and OPPO here are the two main vendors who attempted to differentiate themselves through implementing high level optical magnification in their units. This was mainly achieved by using a more innovative right-angled orientation of the camera sensor inside of the body of the phone, viewing the outside world through the help of a mirror prism. The system does work very well to achieve high magnification levels, however the limitation of the sensor size as well as the very small aperture of the optics systems generally results in lesser picture quality in terms of exposures or dynamic range, to the point that I found these systems to be more or less just simple gimmicks, rather than practical competitors more traditional optical 3x magnification modules.
Sony’s IMX586 – An Absurd Amount of Design Wins
The very first IMX586 device we’ve reviewed this year was the Honor View20 in January. Following that, we’ve seen a stupendous number of smartphones employing Sony’s new sensor. It’s been employed by Honor in many more product ranges, it’s the sensor powering Xiaomi’s flagship devices, OnePlus’s 7-series uses the new sensor, OPPO features it in their Reno devices, ASUS has it as the main sensor for their Zenfone 6 and ROG Phone II, and it’s used in a plethora of other devices from Realme, Lenovo, Samsung, Vivo, Nubia, and others.
I don’t think we’ve ever seen a single camera sensor have so much design wins in the industry as the number of phones featuring it is pretty absurd. Whilst the IMX586 isn’t the first modern high-megapixel mobile sensor, that title still goes to Huawei’s exclusive 40MP units introduced last year with the P20’s, it’s been the sensor that has popularized the new sensor technology for the mass-market. (Yes the Nokia 808's sensor was technically first; but with very different technology and no adoption)
Sony here has triggered a new trend, and frankly I’m not sure it’s based as much on technical merit rather than the marketing power of the 48MP figure. As we’ve seen in numerous reviews this year, phones with the quad-Bayer high-MP module didn’t necessarily perform any better than more traditional lower resolution Bayer sensors. In fact, it seems a key selling point of the IMX586 was that it wasn’t necessarily a high-end sensor, and was thus cheaper to produce and sell to vendors, hence its popularity across a wide range of phones at different price-points.
For 2020, it seems that Samsung LSI is aiming to disrupt the high-MP camera sensor market even more with their introduction of 64MP and 108MP sensors. The first devices with the new sensor generation have already been released, and I think the 108MP model featuring a new humongous 1/1.33” sensor size is very promising. It’s rumoured Samsung will be released their next-gen Galaxy-S with a sensor of this calibre, which will be very interesting to see how that pans out.
Computational Photography: The New Normal
Computational photography has been one of the key innovation points of 2018 – it’s been mostly been pioneered by Huawei with the introduction of a tripod-less night mode in last year’s devices. Google was a quick follower with the introduction of Night Sight in the Pixel 3, but other than these two vendors, it still was a rather rare or inexistent aspect to photography for most devices.
2019 has now completely changed this around, and much like the new triple-camera setups, having computational photography modes exemplified by dedicated Night Mode has been a must for most vendors. The vastly improved computational processing power of new SoCs has made this possible for essentially all device vendors, however we’ve seen that software plays a much bigger role, and device vendors need to invest in a lot of R&D into enabling the features.
[ Mate 30 Pro ] - [ P30 Pro ]
[ S10+ (S) ] - [ S10+ (E) ]
[ iPhone 11 Pro ] - [ Pixel 4 ]
[ G8X ] - [ Xperia 1 ]
Samsung notably started the year with the release of the Galaxy S10 without such a mode, but was able to add it in a firmware update in May, continuously improving it over the course of the year, and also making it a key feature during the launch of the Note10 in August.
Apple’s introduction of Night Mode as well as Deep Fusion also finally brought computational photography to iPhones – Deep Fusion particularly was an industry-first which brought new levels of detail to still photography.
Other vendors are also hanging in there – the implementations here range from bad (Xiaomi), to excellent (OPPO). The software development aspect of the camera firmware and processing means that things are continuously changing, and a device reviewed earlier in the year most certainly won’t showcase the same results if it were to be tested now. This also puts a lot of pressure on vendors to be able to deliver a representative implementation early on as it’s rare for reviews to go back and be updated. Alongside always having the same environmental test conditions, this has been another key reason why I always re-test the complete device line-up, in order to have the most up-to-date comparisons between devices for each new review, so make sure to always check out the newest pieces even if it’s about some other device that might not interest you.
Post Your CommentPlease log in or sign up to comment.
View All Comments
linuxgeex - Sunday, December 29, 2019 - linkI know you would prefer that, but I think Apple errors on the side of sanity with the bezels. It's actually nice to be able to hold the phone with one hand without mistakenly triggering gestures because your hand wraps around slightly and hits the active screen areas. It's nice to have an extra 2mm higher on screen keyboard for typing with one hand. It's nice to know that a side impact will result in a slight case crush instead of loss of the display. It's nice having a very very solid frame so when you have it in your front pocket and you lean over a table and your weight is on that phone, it doesn't burst into flame and burn your balls off. lol.
Qasar - Wednesday, January 1, 2020 - linki would prefer an apple phone to have a micro sd slot.. but that's never gonna happen, and that's part of the reason why i have never bought an iphone :-)
ratbert1 - Friday, December 27, 2019 - linkHardware without software is also meaningless.
Andrei (never met an iPhone he didn't like) ignores the elephant in the room. iOS 13. Luckily I only have to use one sparingly for work.
RaduR - Saturday, December 28, 2019 - linkAndrei , do you know that Xiaomi is the 4th largest Phone manufacturer and you are never mentioning it. Not to forget they allways brought something new to the table : Mi Mix - full display way before Apple , Mi Mix 5G way before Samsung , 100 mp camera before everyone else , and they are Qualcomms largest customer . Never in your speech .
I think they are a great company and unlike others they DO have devices meant to out of Asia clients , including phisical shops in Europe.
To mention Oppo ( that is non existent outside China ) and to forget Xiaomi is a mistake . They have one of the best lineups and they are half the price on the same specs compared to anyone else.
Andrei Frumusanu - Sunday, December 29, 2019 - linkI didn't feel they did anything worthwhile in 2019, I mentioned the camera. The Mi9 was a nice phone but at great value but that's about it for them. Oppo had more interesting devices this year.
thecoolnamesweretaken - Saturday, December 28, 2019 - link"We’ve seen some exotic devices in the form of foldable phones for the first time ever."
This should probably be written as "in the form of phones with foldable screens for the first time ever". Otherwise it is ahistorical:
flyingpants265 - Sunday, December 29, 2019 - linkStill waiting for a phone with:
-dual front speakers
-wireless charging, with plastic or kevlar, no freaking "premium feel" glass back, what a bad idea.
-5000mAh battery or more
-At least 2-3 good cameras, i like wide angle especially
-Underwater capability, not "I-leak68"
Why haven't they created a phone with these features? ALL phones should have all these features. Phones should be a commodity item, instead they rely on useless gimmicks to increase their price to $1400+, which means someone (reviewers) aren't doing their job. My Galaxy S3 was $599 on release (2012).
Don't give me that nonsense about being 'too thick', these companies' job is to fit everything into a small package, that's why they make billions in profit. You can easily have a 'pro version' that's around 9mm, like the Droid Razr MAXX which had a 7mm and a 9mm version, 3300mAh was revolutionary at the time (2012), and my LG G7 is only 3000mAh.
Also, I'd like true underwater waterproofing, custom connectors instead of ports, it's a little tough to make them good but it's almost 2020, creating a sealed phone shouldn't be a problem anymore. Just need proper gaskets for speaker/mic, everything else can be eliminated.
And phones should have 5+ years of warranty for when the screen or SoC randomly fails, like my LG G2, and G3, and G4. That's the only way I would EVER consider paying $1000+ for a phone.
Reflex - Sunday, December 29, 2019 - linkLots of us don't value all those features or that configuration like you do. I'll happily take a thinner and lighter phone vs one with a battery that large. I don't value a headphone jack and it, along with microSD run counter to waterproofing. I also don't care about microSD, I've got a terabyte on OneDrive for my photos. I agree with you about wireless charging and the backplate but I'm open to other people having different feature requirements.
That phone might be your ideal, but its not everyone's. And that's okay.
s.yu - Sunday, December 29, 2019 - linkI feel the waterproofing and that plastic there are the most unlikely features, nor do I agree that the body should be plastic.
The connectors are definitely easy, something like the magnetic connectors already available only built in, but I don't think it's as easy as you think making something entirely waterproof, those that actually qualify are rare and bulky devices.
Qasar - Wednesday, January 1, 2020 - link" -dual front speakers " headphones solve that issue
" -headphone jack " agreed
" -wireless charging, with plastic or kevlar, no freaking "premium feel" glass back, what a bad idea. " dont care for wireless charging, the rest... interesting....
" -5000mAh battery or more " would probably make the phone to bulky, and heavy to hold
" -microSD " must have
" -At least 2-3 good cameras, i like wide angle especially " no thanks, i have a standalone camera for that, 1 camera is fine in the phone.
" -Underwater capability, not "I-leak68" " um.... why????